For Sale
426 David Avenue
Port McNicoll, Tay, ON
$549,777
3Bd
2Ba
1,300+sqft
6Parking
148.26 x 109.62 ftlot
$423/sqft
DetachedMLS# S12692920Listed 2026-01-13106 DOM
Heating
Water Heater
Basement
Partially Finished
On the market for 106 days — longer than average. The seller may be open to negotiation.
About this home
Welcome to 426 David Avenue in Port McNicoll, a great opportunity for first-time buyers, investors, handyman or those looking for a property with potential. Tucked away on a quiet dead-end street, this home offers a solid foundation with room to update and make it your own. Featuring three bedrooms and two bathrooms, along with a partially finished walkout basement, there is plenty of space for a growing family or future improvements. The oversized lot provides added value with room to garden, play, or explore potential severance opportunities, while the detached two-car garage offers convenient storage and workspace. Located just steps from the beautiful shores of Georgian Bay and nearby walking trails, this property combines a peaceful setting with excellent upside in a desirable area.
GarageWalkout
Features
- Sump Pump
- Water Heater
- Year Round Living
- Partially Finished
- None
- Bungalow
Financials
Annual Taxes
$2,324
Estimated Rental Income
Entire property$3,200 – $4,800/mo
Rental yield7.0% – 10.5%
*Estimates based on comparable rentals in the area. Actual income may vary.
Market Data — Tay
Days on market106 days
Buyer's MarketSeller's Market
Based on active listings in Tay. Data updates daily.
Our estimate for this home
Estimated range
$659K – $766K
Mid-point $713K · ~$548/sqft
How this listing compares
$659KList · $550K$766K
Medium confidence·Based on 22 port mcnicoll comparables
Estimated range is generated automatically from active comparables and is for informational purposes only. Not an appraisal — contact Aman for a full comparative market analysis that factors in condition, renovations, and positioning.
Getting around
How walkable, bikeable, and transit-friendly this neighbourhood is.
51
/ 100
Walk Score
Somewhat Walkable
44
/ 100
Transit Score
Some Transit
49
/ 100
Bike Score
Somewhat Bikeable
Scores are estimates based on neighbourhood data and are for informational purposes only.
MLS® data courtesy of the Toronto Regional Real Estate Board (TRREB).
The information provided herein must only be used by consumers that have a bona fide interest in the purchase, sale, or lease of real estate and may not be used for any commercial purpose or any other purpose. Listing information is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate by the Toronto Regional Real Estate Board, the listing brokerage, or this website. The trademarks REALTOR®, REALTORS® and the REALTOR® logo are controlled by The Canadian Real Estate Association (CREA) and identify real estate professionals who are members of CREA. MLS®, Multiple Listing Service®, and the associated logos are owned by CREA. Not intended to solicit properties currently listed for sale or buyers under contract.
You may also like
More homes in Tay
Hand-picked listings with a similar price range and style.
For Sale4 h ago
$447,000
Detached
est. $1,960/mo
551 Anglican Church Road, 906 - Bathurst/Burgess & Sherbrooke (Bathurst) Twp
Tay Valley, ON
2 bd
1 ba
900
6
MLS# X13057754Re/Max Hallmark Realty Group
For Sale1 day ago
$629,777
Detached
est. $2,761/mo
45 Mcdermitt Trail, Victoria Harbour
Tay, ON
2+1 bd
2 ba
900
3
MLS# S13054684RE/MAX Georgian Bay Realty Ltd
For Sale1 day ago
$599,777
Detached
est. $2,629/mo
919 Eighth Avenue, Port McNicoll
Tay, ON
3+2 bd
2 ba
900
2
MLS# S13051846RE/MAX Georgian Bay Realty Ltd
For Sale1 day ago
$599,900
Detached
est. $2,630/mo
8 John Dillingno Street, Victoria Harbour
Tay, ON
3 bd
2 ba
900
3.5
MLS# S13053318RE/MAX Georgian Bay Realty Ltd